Probate Disputes
A well-designed, well-implemented estate plan should avoid controversy: when somebody dies, the administration of the estate should be straightforward, with no room for confusion about who gets what. Unfortunately, there are times when things don’t go according to plan. There may be some kind of ambiguity in a written instrument, or some circumstance may have arisen that the document’s drafter failed to anticipate. In other cases, the documents themselves create no controversy, but a beneficiary questions the handling of assets or some other aspect of an executor or trustee’s conduct.
Disputes such as these are regrettable, but they do occur from time to time. Emotions usually run high. An attorney can help the parties get past their feelings, identify the real issues to be addressed, and clarify the communication of relevant information. Ideally, the problem can be resolved without resort to the Courts, since litigation is often time-consuming, costly, and emotionally strenuous for the parties. In many instances, the preparation and distribution of an informal accounting can shed light on the administrative process, thereby putting to rest the suspicions and assuaging the anxieties of the parties.
Nevertheless, some disputes resist amicable, informal resolution. An action arising from a Will or estate is typically filed with the Superior Court of New Jersey, Chancery Division, Probate Part. A party usually initiates such an action with a Verified Complaint and Order to Show Cause. In the complaint, that party sets forth the facts and asks the Court to grant the relief the party seeks. The party also asks the Court to order a hearing date, on which the opposing party must “appear and show cause” why the requested relief should not be granted. Once the Verified Complaint is filed and the Order to Show Cause is entered, the filing party must serve the opposing party. Before the date of the show cause hearing, the opposing party may file written opposition to the relief sought. When the day of the show cause hearing arrives, the matter is typically not decided on the spot. Rather, because the two sides tend to differ in their versions of the relevant facts, the judge usually orders additional fact-finding in the form of discovery, such as the production of documents and the taking of depositions. At any point in the course of this process, the parties may reach a settlement. If they do not, the matter will proceed to a trial before the judge (a “bench trial,” not a jury trial), who will then render a decision and order.